Top 10 Rarest Jellycat Plushies in 2025

The Jellycat collector world is rich with legends, from pastel bunnies only found in boutique exclusives to fantasy creatures that retired before most fans ever glimpsed them on shelves. The search for these ultra-rare plushies, combined with a vibrant online trading and resale community, has turned Jellycat collecting into a bonafide passion—where each plush isn’t just “cute,” but a prized trophy. Why Are Some Jellycats More Sought After Than Others? Some Jellycat plushies gain legendary status in the community due to a mix of scarcity, design uniqueness, and cultural buzz. For obsessed collectors and curious fans alike, here’s the inside scoop on the rarest Jellycats—ranked by rarity, cult status, and jaw-dropping resale value. Whether you love bunnies, dragons, or quirky exclusives, these plushies are the ultimate prize in the Jellycat universe: Top 10 Rarest Jellycat Plushies (2025) Rank Name or Collection Why They’re So Rare Notable Features/Value 1 Bashful Bunny Imogen Ultra-limited, retired bunny—now legendary for pastel coloring, limited UK release, often resold for £600+ “Holy grail” bunny, muted colors 2 Snow Dragon Brief 2020 release, now fiercely hunted by collectors; magical white plush with shimmery wings Demand drives resale over $600 3 Cheryl Cherry Cake Harrods store exclusive, never mass-produced; nearly impossible to find today Collector-market favorite 4 Amuseables Sports Skateboard Surprise hit, limited Amuseables “Sports” drop; quirky design, quickly sold out global stock Sells high on secondhand sites 5 Bashful Kara Bunny Limited 2012 run, highly coveted for unique colors and facial expression Frequently fetches $600+ 6 Snowy Bear Discontinued winter edition, now valued over $1,500 if mint/new So rare, few surface each year 7 Amuseables Sandcastle/Teapot Oddball summer/teatime exclusives—short runs, instantly collected Steadily rising in value 8 Nimbus the Angel Bunny Holiday special, angel wings & halo, limited drop, now “holy grail” status Nearly impossible to find 9 Charlie Crow One of the most distinct, oddball designs, quickly retired Oversized beak, fan favorite 10 Rare Vintage Pudding Frog Sought by old-school collectors (2005), sometimes hits CA$2,000! True “vintage” Jellycat How Are They Evaluated?  Rarity: Fewer produced/available, higher value. Condition: “With tags” (WT), mint, and smoke-free provenance are gold standards. Originality: Unique character or thematic design can elevate even newer releases to sought-after status. Market Value: Active sales and auction prices on communities like eBay, Reddit, and Facebook set the benchmark for what’s considered “rare.” Collector Sentiment: Sometimes, sentimental attachment or an iconic status within the community can make a plush suddenly skyrocket in popularity, even if it wasn’t rare at first. If hunting mythical plushies is your passion, these are the Jellycats worth chasing—and bragging about when you finally catch one! Ready to add a legendary find to your collection? Shop the rarest, most coveted Jellycats now at PrincessPea.ca!